Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is one of New York City’s most vibrant neighborhoods, known for its artsy vibe, eclectic nightlife, and, of course, its incredible food scene. Whether you’re wrapping up a night out or simply craving a cheesy slice in the wee hours, finding the best pizza in Williamsburg is a must.
Luckily, this neighborhood offers a variety of late-night pizza joints that serve everything from classic New York-style slices to gourmet pies with inventive toppings. Here are the top spots for late-night pizza in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
L’Industrie Pizzeria
If you’re a true pizza lover, you’ve probably heard of L’Industrie Pizzeria. This small but mighty pizzeria has built a cult following, and for good reason. The thin, crispy crust, high-quality ingredients, and signature burrata-topped slices make it a must-visit. Open until midnight on weekends, it’s the perfect place to grab a late-night bite.
The Margherita pizza is a classic, but don’t sleep on their white slice with ricotta and truffle oil. L’Industrie also offers sandwiches and salads, so if you’re with someone who isn’t in the mood for pizza, they’ll still find something delicious.
Best Pizza
With a name like Best Pizza, expectations are high—and this Williamsburg staple does not disappoint. Located on Havemeyer Street, Best Pizza is open until midnight, offering delicious, no-frills, wood-fired slices that keep locals and visitors coming back.
The white pie, featuring a sesame-seed crust and caramelized onions, stands out, and the grandma slice is an essential late-night indulgence. They also serve sandwiches and sides, such as garlic knots, which are great additions to pizza orders.
Joe’s Pizza
No pizza roundup is complete without Joe’s Pizza. Originally a Greenwich Village legend, this iconic NYC pizzeria expanded to Williamsburg, and it has quickly become a favorite. Open until 2 a.m. on weekends, Joe’s serves up some of the best pizza in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
Their classic cheese slice, with the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese on a foldable crust, is the ultimate late-night snack. Joe’s is a go-to spot for people heading home from bars or concerts, making it a lively place to grab a slice late at night.
Vinnie’s Pizzeria
A beloved Williamsburg institution, Vinnie’s Pizzeria is known for its quirky, creative slices and vegan-friendly options. Open until 1 a.m. on weekends, Vinnie’s is perfect for night owls looking for something beyond the ordinary.
Their “Pizza on Pizza” slice, which features mini slices of pizza as a topping, is a must-try. If you’re plant-based, their vegan buffalo chicken slice is a game-changer. They also have a great selection of sandwiches, salads, and sides, making it a versatile late-night option.
Williamsburg Pizza
For those who prefer a balance between classic and modern, Williamsburg Pizza offers some of the best late-night pizza in Williamsburg. Open until midnight on weekends, this spot is known for its fresh ingredients and attention to detail.
Their Sicilian slices are a fan favorite, boasting a crispy yet airy crust with a perfect tomato-to-cheese ratio. If you’re craving a unique flavor, their honey-drizzled pepperoni slice is a must-try. Williamsburg Pizza also has gluten-free options, making it a great choice for those with dietary restrictions.
Leo
If you’re in the mood for something more refined but still want that pizza fix, Leo is an excellent option. Open until midnight, Leo specializes in naturally leavened dough, giving their pizzas a unique, slightly tangy flavor.
The clam pie and cacio e pepe pizza are standouts, making this a go-to for foodies looking for a late-night bite in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. In addition to pizza, Leo also offers a great selection of wines and small plates, making it an ideal spot for a more relaxed late-night meal.
Emmy Squared
For those who love Detroit-style pizza, Emmy Squared is the spot to visit. While they’re known for their thick, crispy, and cheesy crusts, their late-night hours make them even more appealing.
Open until midnight on weekends, their “Colony” pizza—topped with pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey—is a favorite among late-night diners. Pair it with their legendary burger for the ultimate comfort meal. If you’re looking for something beyond pizza, their waffle fries and salads are also solid choices.
Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop
While Paulie Gee’s sit-down restaurant may close earlier, their slice shop stays open late, serving up some of the best pizza in Williamsburg. Their Sicilian-style slices, loaded with cheese and fresh tomato sauce, are worth the trip.
Open until 2 a.m. on weekends, this is a prime destination for those who need a high-quality slice after a night out. The shop offers a rotating selection of creative slices, including vegan options, making it a popular choice for all kinds of pizza lovers.
Where to Stay While Getting Your Pizza Fix!
After indulging in the best late-night pizza in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, you’ll want a comfortable place to rest. Arlo Williamsburg offers a stylish and convenient stay in the heart of the neighborhood, placing you within walking distance of these top pizza spots. In fact, Sungold, the restaurant in Arlo Williamsburg is house made from tthe brick pizza oven. With its modern amenities and rooftop views, it’s the perfect home base for food lovers exploring Williamsburg’s vibrant dining scene. Plus, after a night of pizza hopping, you’ll love relaxing in the hotel’s cozy, well-designed rooms.
